Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Moderators: Bearbonesnorm, Taylor, Chew
- AndyTheBikeGuy
- Posts: 228
- Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2018 2:34 pm
- Location: Lake District
Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I'm in the market for a Ti bike, I've recently ridden a Sonder Camino Ti, which was honestly the best bike I've ever ridden. However, I have a Rose Cross bike which is just about passable for the gravel/adventure mile munching at the moment and I fancy upgrading my Ramin 3+ instead. (May well look at a Camino Ti in a few years anyway).
I'm looking for something I can BP on and also ride all day in the Lakeland fells as I live in SW Cumbria and everything I ride tends to be rocky bridleway, rocky descents and then road in between. The Sonder Broken Road seems the best compromise, but I was wondering what it would be like living with the drawbacks of a hooliganesque Sonder Signal Ti on longer less technically demanding routes? (Ultimate aim is TD, but worry Signal Ti would too big a drawback for that?)
I'm looking for something I can BP on and also ride all day in the Lakeland fells as I live in SW Cumbria and everything I ride tends to be rocky bridleway, rocky descents and then road in between. The Sonder Broken Road seems the best compromise, but I was wondering what it would be like living with the drawbacks of a hooliganesque Sonder Signal Ti on longer less technically demanding routes? (Ultimate aim is TD, but worry Signal Ti would too big a drawback for that?)
- Specialist Hoprocker
- Posts: 323
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2017 9:31 am
- Location: Deepest Darkest Surrey
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Dunno about the Signal but.... I've done bike parks and bike packing on my Stanton Sherpa and that comes in Ti flavour. Honestly the best bike I've ever owned.
- Bearbonesnorm
- Posts: 23983
- Joined: Sun Jun 05, 2011 8:53 pm
- Location: my own little world
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Hadn't really noticed the Signal before but I can't really see why it couldn't be built into a light enough mile muncher. The TD isn't technical but comfort / fit will be important ... so if it works for you.
I do know there's a number of folk on here who ride Titus Firelines and like them - just a thought.
I do know there's a number of folk on here who ride Titus Firelines and like them - just a thought.
May the bridges you burn light your way
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I've been looking at the signal too for a more modern mtb then my trusty inbred 26"
Think I'll have to get a demo
10 year frame warranty
Think I'll have to get a demo
10 year frame warranty
Trying to ride bikes.
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
one of those really given where you live [ lucky bastard] but no one bike is going to be perfect for all the terrain available. If i only had to have one it would probably be similar to what you have for all round perfromance. However realistically I would have a Largish travel FS [and another bk for what you describe] as the fun stuff will be so much more fun on that and i could live with it on the rest of the terrain, Not living there only my FS ever goes to the lakes now.
In the 18 months i lived there I did one CX bike ride [ first half of the jenn ride/lakeland 100 basically]- its seemed a waste with all those proper mountains available
YMMV but that bike looks capable of doing what you want it to do
In the 18 months i lived there I did one CX bike ride [ first half of the jenn ride/lakeland 100 basically]- its seemed a waste with all those proper mountains available
YMMV but that bike looks capable of doing what you want it to do
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
If you have a look in fb for the Sonder owners group, there have been a few posts recently about the signal ti. It seems to be loved very much by people that have them. There is a reason you don’t see many Sonders second hand, and most owners (myself included) end up with more than one Sonder.AndyTheBikeGuy wrote: ↑Fri May 31, 2019 6:43 pm I'm in the market for a Ti bike, I've recently ridden a Sonder Camino Ti, which was honestly the best bike I've ever ridden. However, I have a Rose Cross bike which is just about passable for the gravel/adventure mile munching at the moment and I fancy upgrading my Ramin 3+ instead. (May well look at a Camino Ti in a few years anyway).
I'm looking for something I can BP on and also ride all day in the Lakeland fells as I live in SW Cumbria and everything I ride tends to be rocky bridleway, rocky descents and then road in between. The Sonder Broken Road seems the best compromise, but I was wondering what it would be like living with the drawbacks of a hooliganesque Sonder Signal Ti on longer less technically demanding routes? (Ultimate aim is TD, but worry Signal Ti would too big a drawback for that?)
- AndyTheBikeGuy
- Posts: 228
- Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2018 2:34 pm
- Location: Lake District
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Thanks all, I think I might have to sort a test ride out and see what it’s like for longer days.
Joined the Sonder Owners group which is good info - thanks!
Joined the Sonder Owners group which is good info - thanks!
- Escape Goat
- Posts: 2616
- Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2018 10:41 pm
- Location: Not nearly close enough to Scotland...
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I'm late to this party as I've just put myself back in bike dilemma.
I was thinking on getting a sonder signal to recon 11 or 12 speed....
This came after I liked the Broken Road but as I want 29 x 2.6 I may as well consider the signal. I could use this for long off Road routes in the lakes and certain bear bones events...This may make my Wednesday 29plus surplus to requirement. What are people's thoughts? I didn't want to make a new topic as it's kinda still on this topic. Thanks.
I was thinking on getting a sonder signal to recon 11 or 12 speed....
This came after I liked the Broken Road but as I want 29 x 2.6 I may as well consider the signal. I could use this for long off Road routes in the lakes and certain bear bones events...This may make my Wednesday 29plus surplus to requirement. What are people's thoughts? I didn't want to make a new topic as it's kinda still on this topic. Thanks.
My Movie Channel: https://tinyurl.com/YoutubeEG
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Neil Sutton at Alpkit, did say recently that a Steel version is in the works.
- Attachments
-
- 61934693_10156642661057945_4491632650187964416_n.jpg
- (86.04 KiB) Downloaded 2187 times
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
and from another Alpkit interview.
Join the Sonder Owners Club on Facebook to stay upto date on the the latest news.
Join the Sonder Owners Club on Facebook to stay upto date on the the latest news.
- Attachments
-
- 61311551_10157227598496564_9190270646595092480_n.jpg
- (138.63 KiB) Downloaded 2187 times
-
- Posts: 421
- Joined: Mon Sep 09, 2013 8:03 pm
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I,ve demoed one and its ace such a fun bike
https://singletrackworld.com/forum/topi ... ti-signal/
https://singletrackworld.com/forum/topi ... ti-signal/
- Escape Goat
- Posts: 2616
- Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2018 10:41 pm
- Location: Not nearly close enough to Scotland...
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I think this may be happening.....I can't stop it
My Movie Channel: https://tinyurl.com/YoutubeEG
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Broken Road takes 29 x 2.6. Same dilema and chose Broken Road due to huge frame bag and bottle capacity, whilst still reasonably progressive geometry. Allen, surprised didnt borrow mine on WRT? Welcome to have a go on Jennride?Escape Goat wrote: ↑Tue Jun 18, 2019 9:28 pm I'm late to this party as I've just put myself back in bike dilemma.
I was thinking on getting a sonder signal to recon 11 or 12 speed....
This came after I liked the Broken Road but as I want 29 x 2.6 I may as well consider the signal. I could use this for long off Road routes in the lakes and certain bear bones events...This may make my Wednesday 29plus surplus to requirement. What are people's thoughts? I didn't want to make a new topic as it's kinda still on this topic. Thanks.
- Escape Goat
- Posts: 2616
- Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2018 10:41 pm
- Location: Not nearly close enough to Scotland...
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I didn't know I had this problem till now, so I wouldn't have noticed to have a spin! I love the look of the signal, I could still carry 3 water bottles using two feed bags and one downtube... plus it's a smidge cheaper than the Broken Road...
If I've not sorted something I may just ask you that! What build did you have on it again?
If I've not sorted something I may just ask you that! What build did you have on it again?
My Movie Channel: https://tinyurl.com/YoutubeEG
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
You could have a custom one with even more bottle bosses. Just sayin.......
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
XL Frame up build. Fox 34 perf elite 110mm forks. Shimano 1 x 10 11-46, hope brakes and wheels. Now got new rims 30mm internal, 2.25 rear/2.4 front. No dropper (at the moment). Just let me know whenEscape Goat wrote: ↑Tue Jun 18, 2019 10:29 pm I didn't know I had this problem till now, so I wouldn't have noticed to have a spin! I love the look of the signal, I could still carry 3 water bottles using two feed bags and one downtube... plus it's a smidge cheaper than the Broken Road...
If I've not sorted something I may just ask you that! What build did you have on it again?
Duncan makes a good point about the customisation. Extra bottle bosses on Signal possible, or a Broken road without the sliding dropouts and more rowdy geo.
Or go straight to Waltly, where Sonder get them from.
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
120mm travel forks?
https://nordestcycles.com/en/product/britango-ti-frame
100mm forks or rigid
https://nordestcycles.com/en/product/sardinha-ti-frame
Or even 160mm forks
https://nordestcycles.com/en/product/bardino-ti-frame
All available in steel too!!
I have a sardinha in steel. Its very nice but I spend rather too much time looking at the ti sardihna and the ti britango.
I do knownindont need to change mine, but...
*I also know ive posted a fair few nordest links, but they dont seem that well known and are nice and good value it seems. But ill stop it now
https://nordestcycles.com/en/product/britango-ti-frame
100mm forks or rigid
https://nordestcycles.com/en/product/sardinha-ti-frame
Or even 160mm forks
https://nordestcycles.com/en/product/bardino-ti-frame
All available in steel too!!
I have a sardinha in steel. Its very nice but I spend rather too much time looking at the ti sardihna and the ti britango.
I do knownindont need to change mine, but...
*I also know ive posted a fair few nordest links, but they dont seem that well known and are nice and good value it seems. But ill stop it now
- Escape Goat
- Posts: 2616
- Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2018 10:41 pm
- Location: Not nearly close enough to Scotland...
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Yeah I've seen those before, but I don't want to fall into the "I'll just buy a frame" trap. Even if the tram was 100 quid, it always ends up being so, so expensive.
My Movie Channel: https://tinyurl.com/YoutubeEG
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
I had a good go on the Signal Ti when trying to decide which HT to go for.
If I was to have one bike for everything it would be the Signal.
It felt spot on fit wise, loved the geo for the more full on side of things and it rolled/covered ground with ease.
The space for big 29'' rubber gives great options for normal tyres and mud plugging.
I like the custom extra bottle bosses.
In the end I went with a carbon Transmitter as I specifically wanted a razor sharp handling woodland single track type thing to compliment my fully rigid Kinisis FF29 and my bombproof build Spesh Enduro. Thus far the Transmitter has done nothing but impress, the happiest I've ever been with a bike, fast as, fun and very well made.
As for going straight to Waltly, it's an option but I would say Alpkit are an outstanding company to work with. Great communication, outstanding customer service and a solid warranty.... worth any premium.
There is a Signal in my future.... it's just a matter of when.
If I was to have one bike for everything it would be the Signal.
It felt spot on fit wise, loved the geo for the more full on side of things and it rolled/covered ground with ease.
The space for big 29'' rubber gives great options for normal tyres and mud plugging.
I like the custom extra bottle bosses.
In the end I went with a carbon Transmitter as I specifically wanted a razor sharp handling woodland single track type thing to compliment my fully rigid Kinisis FF29 and my bombproof build Spesh Enduro. Thus far the Transmitter has done nothing but impress, the happiest I've ever been with a bike, fast as, fun and very well made.
As for going straight to Waltly, it's an option but I would say Alpkit are an outstanding company to work with. Great communication, outstanding customer service and a solid warranty.... worth any premium.
There is a Signal in my future.... it's just a matter of when.
- Escape Goat
- Posts: 2616
- Joined: Thu Nov 01, 2018 10:41 pm
- Location: Not nearly close enough to Scotland...
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Thanks for the response. In dewp in coversation with them. This kinda started when I spoke to Rich back in Feb about a frontier...it since escalated....
My Movie Channel: https://tinyurl.com/YoutubeEG
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allen.boardman
-
- Posts: 334
- Joined: Wed Dec 30, 2015 6:25 pm
- Location: manchester
Re: Is a Signal Ti preposterous for long trips?
Apologies if this counts as a hijack. Any idea how the signal compares to the solarisMAX?
From my very limited skills they are almost identical weight. Both look very relaxed. I can see the signal will take a slightly longer fork, but the cotic has more options on wheel size.
From my very limited skills they are almost identical weight. Both look very relaxed. I can see the signal will take a slightly longer fork, but the cotic has more options on wheel size.