Damage to carbon frame
Moderators: Bearbonesnorm, Taylor, Chew
Damage to carbon frame
So there I am, giving my bike it’s final clean and check before the highland trail, take it out of the stand, lean it against the wall, turn round and it falls over
It hit a concrete edge on a small wall, taking a small chunk out of the top tube and another deep scratch out of one of the seat stays.
So how bad is it? No cracking - the stay damage looks like scratching and the top tube damage is rough feeling like a couple of chips of the carbon came out. Worse damage I’ve done to my frame in three years! Flippin annoyed!
Is it likely to have affected the integrity of the carbon or just cosmetic?
It hit a concrete edge on a small wall, taking a small chunk out of the top tube and another deep scratch out of one of the seat stays.
So how bad is it? No cracking - the stay damage looks like scratching and the top tube damage is rough feeling like a couple of chips of the carbon came out. Worse damage I’ve done to my frame in three years! Flippin annoyed!
Is it likely to have affected the integrity of the carbon or just cosmetic?
-
- Posts: 9394
- Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2016 8:19 am
- Location: Dewsbury, West Yorkshire
Re: Damage to carbon frame
What frameset is it please Chris?? Not all are created equally and alot can depend on he initial weight aswell..
Any pics of the damage??
(Sorry for the situation btw)
Any pics of the damage??
(Sorry for the situation btw)
Re: Damage to carbon frame
A read through this (if you haven't already) may give you a fee hints on how to inspect the damage.
Of course we're no experts, but some of the advice like checking on the sound when knocking on the damage, checking if the damaged area is soft under pressure etc. is what I learned from folks who are involved in design and manufacture or fixing carbon frames.
viewtopic.php?f=7&t=19650&hilit=M%C3%A4se
Good luck and hopefully loads of fun with your bike on the HT550.
Of course we're no experts, but some of the advice like checking on the sound when knocking on the damage, checking if the damaged area is soft under pressure etc. is what I learned from folks who are involved in design and manufacture or fixing carbon frames.
viewtopic.php?f=7&t=19650&hilit=M%C3%A4se
Good luck and hopefully loads of fun with your bike on the HT550.
-
- Posts: 9394
- Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2016 8:19 am
- Location: Dewsbury, West Yorkshire
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Just to add to the 'pressing down'... if it feels soft then don't press anymore and it's a surefire indication it needs repairing/expert help.
There's a youtube chap from Australia (luescher I think), called carbon fibre repair. Expert in that field and you'd learn loads from him.
As a general rule, carbon isn't as soft as what we've always been lead yo think and just falling over (unless it's some super special weight weenie bike) shouldn't cause it that much issue. If you look through my history Chris you'll notice that I took a hammer and dremel to mine and a couple of carbon blades... Couldn't actually break it properly (Sonder Transmitter carbon which was at about 1100g for the frame) and ended up giving up. You'd be surprised how strong these things are
There's a youtube chap from Australia (luescher I think), called carbon fibre repair. Expert in that field and you'd learn loads from him.
As a general rule, carbon isn't as soft as what we've always been lead yo think and just falling over (unless it's some super special weight weenie bike) shouldn't cause it that much issue. If you look through my history Chris you'll notice that I took a hammer and dremel to mine and a couple of carbon blades... Couldn't actually break it properly (Sonder Transmitter carbon which was at about 1100g for the frame) and ended up giving up. You'd be surprised how strong these things are
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Merida big nine. I have a pic which I’ll try to upload. Certainly doesn’t feel soft when I push on it.redefined_cycles wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 12:42 pm What frameset is it please Chris?? Not all are created equally and alot can depend on he initial weight aswell..
Any pics of the damage??
(Sorry for the situation btw)
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Thanks will have a read right now.Alpinum wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 12:48 pm A read through this (if you haven't already) may give you a fee hints on how to inspect the damage.
Of course we're no experts, but some of the advice like checking on the sound when knocking on the damage, checking if the damaged area is soft under pressure etc. is what I learned from folks who are involved in design and manufacture or fixing carbon frames.
viewtopic.php?f=7&t=19650&hilit=M%C3%A4se
Good luck and hopefully loads of fun with your bike on the HT550.
-
- Posts: 9394
- Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2016 8:19 am
- Location: Dewsbury, West Yorkshire
Re: Damage to carbon frame
In that case, FWIW and my experiment with the Sonder (it was unrideable anyway so in the interests of market research) I'd ride that (your Merida). Won't tell you what else i ride in carbon flavour that's scuffedChrisS wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 12:59 pmMerida big nine. I have a pic which I’ll try to upload. Certainly doesn’t feel soft when I push on it.redefined_cycles wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 12:42 pm What frameset is it please Chris?? Not all are created equally and alot can depend on he initial weight aswell..
Any pics of the damage??
(Sorry for the situation btw)
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Carbon is bloody strong so its all down to whether its structural or top coat - iwouldbe surprised if that damged it personally
Having thumped a broken on one frame* - others have had a few swings as well - thry cn take some serious impacts
Good luck and hope its fine
* seat clamp areaso it creaks I wasswinging it over my head hitting the ground and bricks as hard as i could.I got bored after about 10 goes.
Having thumped a broken on one frame* - others have had a few swings as well - thry cn take some serious impacts
Good luck and hope its fine
* seat clamp areaso it creaks I wasswinging it over my head hitting the ground and bricks as hard as i could.I got bored after about 10 goes.
- UnderTheRadars
- Posts: 409
- Joined: Mon Jun 02, 2014 8:12 pm
- Location: Stourbridge/North Col of North Worcestershire Alps
Re: Damage to carbon frame
A few years ago now I had good fun trying to smash up prototype and warrantied carbon frames for the skip. Swinging them against the side of the skip with my full strength did surprisingly little damage at first.
Was as shame that I couldn't have one or two
Was as shame that I couldn't have one or two
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Ok I’m feeling a bit better now after reading these comments... the force wasn’t that great as the bike just toppled and hit an edge about half a metre away. The cosmetic damage is annoying but I’ll get over that. Luckily it’s invisiframed so that’s protected it a bit. There’s definitely no softness at all when I push at the damage.
- fatbikephil
- Posts: 6583
- Joined: Wed Apr 02, 2014 10:51 pm
- Location: Fife
- Contact:
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Would it not have just chipped the gel coat over the carbon tube = no damage to fibres so no structural issues?
I'd be tempted to fill the chip in with araldite as much for cosmetics as anything else.
I'd be tempted to fill the chip in with araldite as much for cosmetics as anything else.
-
- Posts: 9394
- Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2016 8:19 am
- Location: Dewsbury, West Yorkshire
Re: Damage to carbon frame
According to onw of the carbon repair shops (as read in Rouleur years ago) its nail varnish. Tha way you can keep an eye on the area cos if you start getting any problems in the rigid/stiff carbon it'll show up as a crack/hairline crack in the nail varnish uaed as top coat. I imagine some clear oil based laquer might do a similar job...
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Yeah I think so. I'm going to tape over it anyhow as it's where one of my framebag straps goes. Once I'm back from the HT I'll probably need to peel off the invisiframe wrap and then see if I can improve it cosmetically. Decided not to worry about it right now!
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Noted thanksChrisS wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 4:08 pmYeah I think so. I'm going to tape over it anyhow as it's where one of my framebag straps goes. Once I'm back from the HT I'll probably need to peel off the invisiframe wrap and then see if I can improve it cosmetically. Decided not to worry about it right now!
- stevenshand
- Posts: 267
- Joined: Tue Jan 29, 2013 4:45 pm
- Contact:
Re: Damage to carbon frame
I've seen this and similar comments before and it's worth mentioning that checking the strength of something by hitting it with a hammer doesn't really tell you much about how strong it is other than the ability to withstand being hit with a hammer. Those kind of forces don't really fall into the category of failure modes in the bicycle world.redefined_cycles wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 12:56 pm If you look through my history Chris you'll notice that I took a hammer and dremel to mine and a couple of carbon blades... Couldn't actually break it properly (Sonder Transmitter carbon which was at about 1100g for the frame) and ended up giving up. You'd be surprised how strong these things are
Bicycle frame testing is mainly about fatigue testing. You deflect part of the frame (ideally in a way that is similar to pedalling forces) thousands of times or until it fails (breaks/cracks/whatever).
I'd struggle to break a paperclip with a hammer but it wouldn't take long for me to break it by repeatedly bending it.
I'd be willing to place a very large bet that if you take a chip out of your top tube then the frame will fail sooner than one without the chip if both frames are subjected to the same fatigue testing, I'm not saying it will break in normal use anytime soon however. It may be that the damaged frame survives a loading cycle many thousands of times, perhaps equivalent to many tens of years of riding.
I obviously can't speculate if your frame is going to break or not but I do think it's important to differentiate the difference between being able to withstand being hit with a hammer and breaking while riding.
-
- Posts: 9394
- Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2016 8:19 am
- Location: Dewsbury, West Yorkshire
- Cheeky Monkey
- Posts: 3915
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2011 1:48 pm
- Location: Leeds ish
- Contact:
Re: Damage to carbon frame
You're going to ruin everybody's fun if you keep coming on here with your informed and balanced opinions based on experience and knowledgestevenshand wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 4:52 pmI've seen this and similar comments before and it's worth mentioning that checking the strength of something by hitting it with a hammer doesn't really tell you much about how strong it is other than the ability to withstand being hit with a hammer. Those kind of forces don't really fall into the category of failure modes in the bicycle world.redefined_cycles wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 12:56 pm If you look through my history Chris you'll notice that I took a hammer and dremel to mine and a couple of carbon blades... Couldn't actually break it properly (Sonder Transmitter carbon which was at about 1100g for the frame) and ended up giving up. You'd be surprised how strong these things are
Bicycle frame testing is mainly about fatigue testing. You deflect part of the frame (ideally in a way that is similar to pedalling forces) thousands of times or until it fails (breaks/cracks/whatever).
I'd struggle to break a paperclip with a hammer but it wouldn't take long for me to break it by repeatedly bending it.
I'd be willing to place a very large bet that if you take a chip out of your top tube then the frame will fail sooner than one without the chip if both frames are subjected to the same fatigue testing, I'm not saying it will break in normal use anytime soon however. It may be that the damaged frame survives a loading cycle many thousands of times, perhaps equivalent to many tens of years of riding.
I obviously can't speculate if your frame is going to break or not but I do think it's important to differentiate the difference between being able to withstand being hit with a hammer and breaking while riding.
Re: Damage to carbon frame
WeaklingI'd struggle to break a paperclip with a hammer
Great post though.
- stevenshand
- Posts: 267
- Joined: Tue Jan 29, 2013 4:45 pm
- Contact:
Re: Damage to carbon frame
I'm sorry, I forgot where I was for a moment. I will stick to inflammatory, ill-informed posts from now on.Cheeky Monkey wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 5:13 pm You're going to ruin everybody's fun if you keep coming on here with your informed and balanced opinions based on experience and knowledge
- voodoo_simon
- Posts: 4083
- Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2013 9:05 pm
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Reminds me of this, those unbreakable (is that a word?) phone case that are solid without a phone in them
https://youtu.be/VAsa3EZmahE
https://youtu.be/VAsa3EZmahE
- Cheeky Monkey
- Posts: 3915
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2011 1:48 pm
- Location: Leeds ish
- Contact:
Re: Damage to carbon frame
stevenshand wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 5:47 pmI'm sorry, I forgot where I was for a moment. I will stick to inflammatory, ill-informed posts from now on.Cheeky Monkey wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 5:13 pm You're going to ruin everybody's fun if you keep coming on here with your informed and balanced opinions based on experience and knowledge
Always good to hear stuff though, everyday (can be) a school day
-
- Posts: 8144
- Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 9:56 am
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Always worth a re-post
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5eMMf11uhM
FF to 5:00 to skip the "scientific" bits
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5eMMf11uhM
FF to 5:00 to skip the "scientific" bits
-
- Posts: 9394
- Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2016 8:19 am
- Location: Dewsbury, West Yorkshire
Re: Damage to carbon frame
Thanks so much Colin. My Highball is coming at some point this month (won't be able to ride it for a good year though as I save and buy parts) hopefully. This vid just bought a smile to my face as did my Superlight of yesteryear (last nice full sus I owned).ScotRoutes wrote: ↑Fri May 14, 2021 8:04 pm Always worth a re-post
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5eMMf11uhM
FF to 5:00 to skip the "scientific" bits