OK - so I commute to work in Norway by bicycle and we have proper winters here, but also have more clod and wet days than full on cold and dry. As you all know, cold and wet is the worst possible combination for gloves to have to protect again. So what do I use for winter:
My go to gloves (the ones I use last night at just above freezing, and every commute since September) are only £7.99 out of sale times (picked up several pairs in one of the sales for £4.99 a pop
https://www.planetx.co.uk/i/q/CLCARULRA ... aix-gloves
I love these gloves, not because they are warm (they are not warm) or waterproof (no, not waterproof either) what the do excell at is dexterity, comfort (they fit me like umm.. a glove), cheap, last ages, can use my phone, dry fast in work, thin enough to be a liner in other gloves, more than warn enough for 90% of my commutes etc.
I have become accustomed to wet hands whilst cycling and TBH expect it, but can put up with it as long as I have the dexterity to control my bike and
the wind is kept out, then all is good.
When its around zero and raining (yes we get a lot of that too) then I move up to these:
https://www.planetx.co.uk/i/q/CLCARULWB ... ock-gloves
Again, same reasons as above, will get wet but block the wind and that (for me) is the important bit. Soggy wet hands that are not frozen and can fell the bars (dexterity)
is way more preferable to clammy warm hands and zero dexterity of most (well, all of the waterproof insulated) gloves, I have tried.
In full on winter, (-15 etc) it cold enough to be dry and then my ski gloves come out.
We are all different but the 2 gloves above are cheap and IMHO rather nice gloves.