rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Moderators: Bearbonesnorm, Taylor, Chew
rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Planning (well considering) a bikepacking trip across the interior of Iceland.
Given the lack of resupply points, and need for more gear I doubt regular bikepacking bags will have enough capacity.
So, thought a set of panniers.
Of the two, which would people recommend, a front or rear rack?
Given the lack of resupply points, and need for more gear I doubt regular bikepacking bags will have enough capacity.
So, thought a set of panniers.
Of the two, which would people recommend, a front or rear rack?
- TheBrownDog
- Posts: 2108
- Joined: Thu Mar 14, 2013 8:46 pm
- Location: Chilterns
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
It'd be a rear rack for me. Panniers on the front make wheel lifts and hike-a-bike a lot harder. But's that's just me. Rather than panniers, what about a big old dry bag strapped to the top of the rack?
I'm just going outside ...
- danielgroves
- Posts: 395
- Joined: Sun Mar 02, 2014 9:55 pm
- Location: Bath/Bristol, UK
- Contact:
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
To give an opposite opinion: front. Rear only is a pain in the arse as the bike will basically try and wheelie overtime you hit a climb on any gradient. Front doesn't mess up the handling *too* much sassing you're keep the wheels on the ground, and makes the weight a lot easier to manage in my opinion.
Adventures and Photography Blog: danielgroves.net/adventures-photography
Twitter: @danielsgroves
Instagram: @danielsgroves
Photography on Facebook: facebook.com/danielgrovesphotography
Photography on Instagram: @danielgrovesphotography
Twitter: @danielsgroves
Instagram: @danielsgroves
Photography on Facebook: facebook.com/danielgrovesphotography
Photography on Instagram: @danielgrovesphotography
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Neither. How about Gorilla cages/mounts for an extra 10L of capacity?
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Count those a front rack vote.ctznsmith wrote:Neither. How about Gorilla cages/mounts for an extra 10L of capacity?
- voodoo_simon
- Posts: 4113
- Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2013 9:05 pm
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Looking at a lot of American sites courtesy of The Radavist, I'd say the front.
Have never tried it though, only on the rear and seems to work well enough
Have never tried it though, only on the rear and seems to work well enough
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Depends on the bike, some handle a front load better than others. I prefer a front rack, it does make lofting the front wheel harder while riding rough terrain, but is much better going uphill, standing pedalling and pushing the bike. There are few things as annoying as having rear panniers bump the back of your legs on a long hike a bike!
Also I think that moving the weight forward off the back wheel reduces stress and the risk of broken spokes.
Also it looks cool.
Also I think that moving the weight forward off the back wheel reduces stress and the risk of broken spokes.
Also it looks cool.
- danielgroves
- Posts: 395
- Joined: Sun Mar 02, 2014 9:55 pm
- Location: Bath/Bristol, UK
- Contact:
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
There you go, justified much better than I did. THat's basically everything that flashed through my mind when I saw the question.Steezysix wrote:Depends on the bike, some handle a front load better than others. I prefer a front rack, it does make lofting the front wheel harder while riding rough terrain, but is much better going uphill, standing pedalling and pushing the bike. There are few things as annoying as having rear panniers bump the back of your legs on a long hike a bike!
Also I think that moving the weight forward off the back wheel reduces stress and the risk of broken spokes.
Also it looks cool.
Adventures and Photography Blog: danielgroves.net/adventures-photography
Twitter: @danielsgroves
Instagram: @danielsgroves
Photography on Facebook: facebook.com/danielgrovesphotography
Photography on Instagram: @danielgrovesphotography
Twitter: @danielsgroves
Instagram: @danielsgroves
Photography on Facebook: facebook.com/danielgrovesphotography
Photography on Instagram: @danielgrovesphotography
- Bearbonesnorm
- Posts: 23985
- Joined: Sun Jun 05, 2011 8:53 pm
- Location: my own little world
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Front, for all the reasons already stated ... except the looking cool part.
I'd also fit a 'platform' type rack. My thinking is you're not limited to panniers and can just strap dry bags to it as required. It'll also provide somewhere secure to dangle your mug from
I'd also fit a 'platform' type rack. My thinking is you're not limited to panniers and can just strap dry bags to it as required. It'll also provide somewhere secure to dangle your mug from
May the bridges you burn light your way
- danielgroves
- Posts: 395
- Joined: Sun Mar 02, 2014 9:55 pm
- Location: Bath/Bristol, UK
- Contact:
Re: rack for an extended trip, front or rear?
Bearbonesnorm wrote:It'll also provide somewhere secure to dangle your mug from
Adventures and Photography Blog: danielgroves.net/adventures-photography
Twitter: @danielsgroves
Instagram: @danielsgroves
Photography on Facebook: facebook.com/danielgrovesphotography
Photography on Instagram: @danielgrovesphotography
Twitter: @danielsgroves
Instagram: @danielsgroves
Photography on Facebook: facebook.com/danielgrovesphotography
Photography on Instagram: @danielgrovesphotography